Carbon or Wood?

Friday, October 7th, 2011

Carbon or Wood?

In this blog series, I will be answering the questions most frequently asked. Should I use a carbon or all-wood blade?

Generally, carbon blades are faster and more suitable for the advanced player. For a beginner, it is best to choose a very slow, controlled wood blade. This will allow the player to develop solid strokes because the ball has more dwell time on the racket. A faster blade is better for an attacking player who makes contact with the ball at the top of the bounce. A controlled blade is better for a defensive or allround player who plays at many different distances from the table.

Wood blades have more feel and vibration than carbon blades. As a beginner, it is important to “feel” the ball. For this reason, I would suggest using an all-wood blade for the first three years. After a player has excellent strokes and feeling, it would be advisable to possibly move up to a carbon blade for added power. At the elite level, players who mainly use power to win points generally play with carbon blades for a hard feel. Elite players who use touch to win points generally play with all-wood blades for a much softer feel.

Carbon blades have a larger sweet-spot due to the reinforced layers and harder feeling of the blade. This will give slightly more room for error if the player doesn’t contact the ball in the center of the racket.

The final factor to consider is the cost. Most wood blades cost between $40-$100. Most carbon blades cost between $60-$200. If a player uses the racket for at least 1 year, paying the extra money is possibly worth it. The racket will last for 5-10 years.

In the first 3 years of playing, I would encourage the beginner to select the 5-ply, all-wood Nittaku Rising blade. For those players wanting to use a fast carbon blade, I would suggest using the Nittaku Survelian. For those players wanting a fast wood blade, I would suggest the Nittaku Ludeack (which I personally use).

Samson Dubina is an accomplished player and coach. He was the US Nationals Men’s Singles Finalist in 2010. Learn more about Samson.

Facebook Like


One Response to “Carbon or Wood?”

  1. random says:

    oh but why not a stiga clipper cc or a andro super core cell off

Leave a Reply

Learn about the author, .

Share This Page
Facebook Facebook
Twitter Twitter
E-mail this page: